Thermocouple Versus RTD

Temperature range:

First, consider the difference in temperature ranges. Noble Metal Thermocouples can reach 3,100 F, while standard RTDs have a limit of 600 F and extended range RTDs have a limit of 1,100 F.

Cost:

A plain stem thermocouple is 2 to 3 times less expensive than a plain stem RTD. A thermocouple head assembly is roughly 50% less expensive than an equivalent RTD head assembly.

Accuracy, Linearity, & Stability:

As a general rule, RTDs are more accurate than thermocouples. This is especially true at lower temperature ranges. RTDs are also more stable and have better linearity than thermocouples. If accuracy, linearity, and stability are your primary concerns and your application is within an RTD’s temperature limits, go with the RTD.

Durability:

In the sensors industry, RTDs are widely regarded as a less durable sensor when compared to thermocouples. However, REOTEMP has developed manufacturing techniques that have greatly improved the durability of our RTD sensors. These techniques make REOTEMP’s RTDs nearly equivalent to thermocouples in terms of durability.

Response Time:

RTDs cannot be grounded. For this reason, they have a slower response time than grounded thermocouples. Also, thermocouples can be placed inside a smaller diameter sheath than RTDs. A smaller sheath diameter will increase response time. For example, a grounded thermocouple inside a 1/16” dia. sheath will have a faster response time than a RTD inside a ¼” dia. sheath.

1 Like

Two most common temperature instruments used in process industry are RTD and thermocouple. To determine which one to use, the following should be considered:

RTD is preferred if one of the following aspects becomes a concern in measurement: Accuracy, Stability, Sensitivity and Linearity.

Thermocouple is preferred in application for high temperature measurement (more than 400 degC) or when exposed to shock or vibration.

This is the reason why projects usually specify RTD for most process temperature measurement, while thermocouple is applied in heater, flare or for vibration monitoring of compressor or pump.

Cost? It depends on the installation. Some panel or I/O card does not accept RTD directly so it requires a transmitter. On the other hand, extension wire would be an additional cost of thermocouple.

1 Like